
Pastor Steve Smothermon v. The Hodge Twins

Attorney

Attorney

Attorney
Keith and Kevin Hodge, aka the Hodgetwins, are famously known for their comedic commentary regarding politics, current events, fitness tips, and relationship advice across their several YouTube channels. (Link to their youtube)
Plaintiff Pastor Steve Smothermon sued the Hodge Twins in federal court for defamation. According to the Complaint, they referred to a Steve Smotherman (the architect of Cracker Barrel’s DEI efforts and its rebranding) as “woke,” “antiAmerican,” and “anti-family values.”
However, they are accused of then posting a picture of Steve Smothermon and not Steve Smotherman.
Can you spot the difference?
Difficult, isn’t it?
In a defamation case, there can be no liability without the requisite level of fault. Since Smothermon (and probably Smotherman too) is a public figure, that level is “actual malice.” What that means is that he will need to prove that the HodgeTwins published the wrong photo with knowledge that they did so, or a reckless disregard for the mistake.
At this time, the case remains pending. Key court documents will be provided, but commentary will be limited until orders begin to issue.
Main Case documents
- Primary Case Pleadings
- Complaint
- Answer
- -
- Smothermon's Motion to Strike Answer
- Smothermon's Motion
- Hodgetwins' Opposition
- Smothermon's Reply
- Order Denying Smothermon's Motion to Strike
- -
- Smothermon's Motion to Amend Complaint
- Smothermon's Motion
- Hodgetwins' Opposition
- Smothermon's Reply
- Smothermon's Motion for a Protective Order
- Smothermon's Motion
- Hodgetwins' Opposition
- Smothermon's Reply
- -
- Hodgetwins' Motion for Summary Judgment / Anti-SLAPP
- Hodgetwins' Motion
- Hodgetwins' Request for Judicial Notice
- Smothermon's Opposition
DIscovery motions
- Hodgetwins' Motion to Compel Document Production
- Hodgetwins' Motion
- Hodgetwins' Notice
- Smothermon's Opposition
- Hodgetwins' Reply
- -
- Smothermon's Motion to Compel Discovery Responses
- Smothermon's Motion
- Hodgetwins' Opposition
- Smothermon's Reply
- Hodgetwins' Motion to Exclude Fisher (Smothermon's Expert)
- Hodgetwins' Motion
- Smothermon's Opposition
- Hodgetwins' Reply
- -
- Smothermon's Motion to Compel Payment to Expert Witness
- Smothermon's Motion
- Hodgetwins' Opposition
- -
- Omnibus Order
Administrative Motions
- Hodgetwins' Emergency Motion to Continue Hearing
- Hodgetwins' Motion
- Smothermon's Opposition
- Hodgetwins' Reply
- Order Denying Motion
- Hodgetwins' Motion to Reconsider Order
- Smothermon's Opposition
- Hodgetwins' Reply
- Order Denying Motion to Reconsider
- -
- Both Parties Motions to Modify the Scheduling Order
- Hodgetwins' Motion to Modify
- Smothermon's Opposition
- -
- Smothermon's Motion to Modify
- Hodgetwins' Opposition
- Hodgetwins' Notice of Errata re Opposition
- -
- Smothermon's Motion to Strike Errata
- Hodgetwins' Opposition to Motion to Strike Errata
- Smothermon's Reply
- Hodgetwins' Motion to Supplement Opposition
- Hodgetwins' Motion for Sanctions
- Hodgetwins' Motion
- Smothermon's Opposition
- Hodgetwins' Reply
- -
- Hodgetwins' Motion for Attorneys' Fees
- Hodgetwins' Motion
- Smothermon's Opposition
- Hodgetwins' Reply