I am not going to comment extensively upon this, since Myself and Jay DeVoy of Randazza Legal Group are counsel for the defendant.
However, I will share that Righthaven filed suit against a guy for posting a news article into a newsgroup. We felt that this was fair use. We moved for summary judgment, and while that motion was pending, we discovered that it seemed that Righthaven did not have standing in the first place. The judge agreed on both grounds, and Mr. Hoehn has prevailed.
Judge Pro’s opinion is here.